Best Foam Gutter Guards: Reviews and Buyers Guide

Gutter cleaning is both a tedious and dangerous job. Having to climb up on a ladder to clean your gutters on a regular basis leaves you exposed to risks that could imply falling and hurting yourself. Gutter guards are products that can prevent that from happening since they narrow down the time spent on a ladder pretty consistently. They are great home improvement tools that can prevent gutters from getting clogged, while also keeping pesky critters away from nesting inside the gutters.

4 Best Foam Gutter Guard Comparisons

IMAGE MODEL FEATURES
byb2-table__imageGutterStuff EZ Foam Gutter Insert
  • Length per Package: 32 or 96 feet
  • Warranty: 3 years
  • Max Gutter Width: 5 inches
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageRainGutter Advanced Foam Gutter Guard
  • Length per Package: 104 feet
  • Warranty: 20 years
  • Max Gutter Width: 5 inches
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageFlo-free Gutter Guard
  • Length per Package: 36 feet
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Max Gutter Width: 6 inches
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageGutterStuff Pro K Style Foam Gutter
  • Length per Package: 32 or 144 feet
  • Warranty: 15 years
  • Max Gutter Width: 5 inches
Check The Price

Common Mistakes When Buying Gutter Guards

There’s no doubt about it: gutter guards are a must-have, especially if your yard is home to a lot of trees. This increased the odds of leaves, insects, and other tree-related debris from clogging the gutter system, leaving you hanging on top of the ladder, doing some sort of risky shenanigans to clean the gutters. However, there are a number of mistakes that people tend to make when they’re out shopping for gutter guards.

Mistake #1: Focusing solely on price.

Stretch Dollar BillWhether you are on a budget or not, the price is an important purchasing factor and should be treated as such. However, people often fall into the trap of constantly questioning a product, wondering why in the world does it have such a high price. Have you ever wondered that perhaps, you are looking at this problem from the wrong angle? The next time you come across a company that sells gutter guards which you feel are overpriced, considering the following questions:

  • What problems could I be facing if I install this sponge gutter guard system?
  • Why do I need gutter guards in the first place?
  • What happens when my gutters get clogged with debris?
  • How much I am really exposing myself to risks when I constantly have to clean gutter all by myself?
  • What do other people feel about this particular gutter guard system?

Mistake #2: Thinking that all gutter guard systems are the same.

Contractor adjusting plastic gutter guards to get them to fit.Plastic guard over new dark grey plastic rain gutter on asphalt shingles roof at shallow depth of field.We can’t really say we blame you on this one. Most of the major brands that sell good gutter guards claim that their product is the best, the safest, with the best warranty, doesn’t damage your roof, doesn’t make your gutters collapse, and is simply a wonder amongst home improvement products.

The important thing to keep in mind is that there isn’t a magical product that’s absolutely perfect for every customer and every situation. Foam inserts, for instance, are a wonderful choice for some people, who simply can’t imagine using anything else. But for people that live in a dusty area or have to face falling pine needles problems the entire time, foam inserts may not the best option.

Since gutter guards have different shapes and attributes and are made from different materials, it makes sense that they aren’t completely identical to one another. Every type of gutter guard can be considered the best choice for particular situations.

For the pine needle problem, for instance, you need a mesh guard that has a very fine surface, without any large holes that would allow needles to infiltrate in the gutters themselves. This mistake is very much tied to the first one. Why would you want to buy an expensive gutter guard if they’re basically all the same?

Mistake #3: Underestimating the long term benefits.

Man cleaning gutters on ladderThe walls of your house, the roof, and the gutter system are actually more related to one another that you know. In fact, it makes sense considering that these three elements are physically connected to one another. Yes, but how does this make gutter guards a good investment?

The shortest answer to this question is this: gutter guards are means to protect your home against weather, and when something bad happens to your gutter, this can affect the walls and the roof of your house, as well. What you need to understand at this point is that the gutter system of your home keeps your walls, your roof, and the foundation of your house protected.

Gutters are attached to walls. When these gutters begin to bend or break under the heavy accumulation of debris, they begin to move further away from your walls, causing damage. When your gutter system does not operate at its full capacity, the water from your roof begins pouring down the exterior walls of your home. This water can eventually reach the foundation of the house, causing even more damage. Conclusion: a healthy and fully functional gutter system keeps other elements of your home’s structure safe.

Mistake #4: Over-trusting salespeople.

Online shopping website on laptop screen with female hands typingOne of the many benefits of ordering stuff on the internet is that you can avoid the nuisance of a salesperson that just won’t let you look around the store, but will rather track you down and hunt you with a million questions and product offers, especially if they are hired on a sales commission-type of earning system.

If you do end up looking for gutter guards by visiting a brick and mortar store, it might be helpful for you to be on the lookout for sales representative trying to sell you features you don’t need. This brings us back to the aforementioned statement, that not all products are the same, which means there isn’t a product perfect for every situation.

Well, you can’t really blame salespeople in this situation. They are so well-trained, they really believe all that stuff they’re trying to sell you, about how their product is the best one in the world, which can completely fix whatever gutter-related problem you may have. They will try to convince you that their product will exceed all your expectations.

Steer clear of salesmen that don’t know how to ask the right questions. Always be skeptical when you’re presented with a magical solution, coming from a person that hasn’t even taken the time to hear about your problem.

In this case, the best thing you can do is educate yourself before going shopping. If the sales representative fails to ask you the right questions, you should be prepared with a list of inquiries of your own. Get objective information and specs that would help you compare several gutter guards. This is the best way to avoid all the fluff and get a product that’s actually right for you.

Top 4 Foam Gutter Guard Reviews

Finding good foam gutter guards is not easy. They are considered to be the underdogs of the gutter guard realm, which makes people pretty skeptical about buying them. However, foam inserts do pose a lot of benefits, but you don’t have to take our word for it. Just look at some of the features and benefits of the top four foam inserts of the moment and see for yourself.

GutterStuff EZ Foam Gutter Insert

GutterStuff EZ Foam Gutter Insert
  • Length per Package: 32 or 96 feet
  • Warranty: 3 years
  • Max Gutter Width: 5 inches
Check The Price

 

Considered one of the most efficient products of its kind, the foam gutter guard manufactured by GutterStuff has a three year warranty period to stand beside the quality of this item. You can opt for the four, five, or six-inch style of gutter guards, each figure is an indicator of the gutter width it’s most suitable for.

Because it’s basically a triangle made from foam, installing this gutter guard is a really fast and easy process since there are no tools required. Because of its simplicity, the system will not, in any way, damage the gutters or mess with the roof, which are two very important things to consider when you’re on the market shopping for gutter guards.

But the most important thing to know is what you can expect from a product like the foam insert made by GutterStuff EZ. Aside from being available in three sizes, you might be interested in knowing that since it fits completely inside the gutter, it’s basically invisible from the ground up, which is a plus for homeowners interested in aesthetics. Aside from that, the foam insert will trap all forms of debris on its surface, but still, allow rainwater to pass through. The UV protection will keep these foam inserts protected from the sun’s damaging rays.

Pros:

  • Invisible from the ground up.
  • UV protected.
  • Three sizes are available.
  • Covers systems up to 96 feet.
  • Easy to install.
  • Doesn’t put pressure on the gutters.
  • Doesn’t require fiddling with the roof.

Cons:

  • Will require maintenance.
  • Will shrink in time.

Pro tip

If you’re looking for foam gutter protectors that are made to be durable, efficient, and easy to install, GutterStuff EZ is a product that meets all of these requirements, and more.

RainGutter Advanced Foam Gutter Guard

RainGutter Advanced Foam Gutter Guard
  • Length per Package: 104 feet
  • Warranty: 20 years
  • Max Gutter Width: 5 inches
Check The Price

 

This gutter guard is made from silicone foam, which should be more resistant compared to other types of foam in the long run. Typically, silicone has five times the lifespan of polyurethane, so RainGutter might be onto something here.

As with most other gutter guards that are made from foam, this one is also very easy to install. The only tool you will require is a Stanley knife. Other than that, there are no screws that need attaching, which means that there are no changes of you voiding the warranty on your current gutter system or your roof.

As advertised, the RainGutter foam inserts will not shrink over time, nor will they ignite. They don’t have UV protection but are UV resistant, which means they can maintain their original shape and efficiency, despite being exposed for many summers under the hot sun.

Pros:

  • Easy to install.
  • No tools required.
  • UV resistant.
  • No added chemicals.
  • Made with durable silicone.

Cons:

  • In very dusty areas, foam inserts may get clogged.

Pro tip

Because these gutter guards are from silicone, they have a longer lifespan compared to regular polyurethane foam, which makes them a solid choice for people who are looking to make a solid investment over the years.

Flo-free Gutter Guard

Flo-free Gutter Guard
  • Length per Package: 36 feet
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Max Gutter Width: 6 inches
Check The Price

 

The design of the Flo-free gutter guards hints that this is a unique product from the get-go. The curved shape of the foam inserts leaves plenty of space underneath them, to allow plenty of rainwater to make its way through the gutters, without any flow restrictions.

As advertised, installing these foam inserts should not take more than two hours on an average-sized home. It allows the rainwater to pass through the surface of the protectors and into the gutter system itself while holding back all forms of debris that could clog the gutters. It’s also very efficient at keeping away insects and vermin that are attracted to damp areas, such as gutters.

The foam is made from industrial-strength nylon and doesn’t require any tools to install (except for a caulking gun), which means that you won’t have to fiddle with the roof, exterior walls, or the gutter system itself. Some other types of gutter guards will weigh heavily down on the gutters, causing them to bend or collapse its time. This is a problem that you won’t have to worry about with foam inserts.

Pros:

  • Unique design.
  • No water flow restrictions.
  • Keep vermin and insects away.
  • Lifetime warranty.
  • UV protection.

Cons:

  • Too small for 6-inch gutters.

Pro tip

The warranty of a product is typically a statement that the company makes, ensuring customers that it stands by the quality of the product it sells. With these Flo-free inserts, you will benefit from a lifetime warranty period, meaning that this product is great for those of you that are particularly interested in this aspect.

GutterStuff Pro K Style Foam Gutter

GutterStuff Pro K Style Foam Gutter
  • Length per Package: 32 or 144 feet
  • Warranty: 15 years
  • Max Gutter Width: 5 inches
Check The Price

 

Since good gutter guards are hard to find, we stumbled across another product made by GutterStuff. This time, we’re talking about a customer favorite, so we’re going to talk a bit about the general opinion of buyers that have actually used this product.

As far as product features are concerned, you will get a gutter guard that’s made with UV protected and germicide imbued foam. It doesn’t require any tools to install, which makes it a hassle-free product for people that simply don’t want to spend too much time suspended on a ladder. The product is backed up by a 15-year performance warranty.

The first thing that customers advise future buyers is to carefully check who is selling the item. There are a lot of cheap copies that simply won’t do the job they were destined to do, so always make sure you check who is offering the product. Due to their lightweight, these foam inserts can easily be cut to match the style of your gutters, if needed. Customers also like that they are invisible, which means that you can’t see them when looking from the ground up.

Pros:

  • Easy to install.
  • Invisible from the ground up.
  • Available in different length packages.
  • UV protected.
  • Coated with germicide.

Cons:

  • Considered expensive by some customers.

Pro tip

The GutterStuff Pro foam inserts have a lot of words of praise addressed by customers that have actually bought and tested this product. If other’s buyer’s opinion means a lot to you when making a shopping decision, this is a product worthy of your attention.

Conclusion

Up to this date, there are people that consider foam guards to be extremely inefficient in keeping gutters protected. It’s true that foam gutters do pose a series of both advantages and downsides, so you may still be wondering why choose this product over others in its category?

First off, foam gutter guards are really easy to install. That’s because they don’t require any fiddling with the walls, roof, or the gutter system itself. They’re mostly the type of product that you just slide in there and have it do its job. Another important advantage is the fact that the foam surface can literally trap any form of debris, while also allowing rainwater to enter the gutters and flow freely.

Leave a Comment

shares