Best Gutter Guards - 2019 Reviews

The Best Gutter Guards for Your Home

If you’ve never purchased gutter guards before, you may be wondering what exactly to look for when scouting the market for such a product. With gutter guards, there are important factors to always look after water flow, air flow, and ease of installation. And if you’re confused by the countless options available in the market, we’re here with tips to help you choose the best one for your home.

Best 7 Gutter Guards Comparison

IMAGE MODEL FEATURES
byb2-table__imageLeafFilter Gutter Guard
  • Type: Micro Mesh complete enclosure
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Material: stainless steel and uPVC
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageGutterBrush Leaf Gutter Guard
  • Type: cylinder-shaped bristles
  • Warranty: 10 Year
  • Material: polypropylene and galvanized steel
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageShur Flo X Leaf Guard Gutter Protector
  • Type: screen gutter guard
  • Warranty: 25 years
  • Material: aluminum
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageAmerimax Home Products 86670 Snap-In Filter Gutter Guard
  • Type: mesh gutter guard
  • Warranty: limited lifetime
  • Material: vinyl and plastic
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageGutterStuff GSEz-K58Box K Style Foam Gutter Filter
  • Type: foam gutter guard
  • Warranty: 3 years performance warranty
  • Material: foam
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageEasyOn Gutter Guard
  • Type: micro-mesh gutter guard
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Material: stainless steel
Check The Price
byb2-table__imageLeafGuard Gutter Guard
  • Type: Seamless aluminum replacement
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime
  • Material: Aluminum
Check The Price

What to Look For

You want to pick a guard which has an excellent water and airflow score. As you know, moist environments are favored by mosquitoes, other types of insects, and even rodents. They tend to crawl up in space with a lot of humidity and start nesting and breeding there. This could run the risk of diseases and viruses.

While a lot of people think that gutters made with the finest mesh are the best choice, because they keep out small debris particles, these types of guards are also the ones that aren’t good at filtering water. When the water flows over, it’s easy to form icicles and ice formations which can pose all sorts of dangers. Proper ventilation is also important because (in not so many elegant words) you don’t want your gutters to stink.

Ease of installation is important because of 1. Nobody wants to spend too much time installing gutters and 2. The more complicated the process is, the more likely you are to damage the roof. If you can choose gutter guards that don’t require any power tools, that would be awesome. If your new guards require a more complicated installation process, you might want to consider hiring a professional (assuming you don’t know how to do that yourself).

Benefits of Using Gutter Guards

As you can imagine, there are different types of guards on the market. They differ from the materials that are used in their construction, up to their capacity of trapping larger or smaller types of debris. Overall, gutter guards are meant to minimize the amount of time and effort you spend cleaning your gutters but can also prolong their lifespan.

Avoiding Infestations

Clogged gutter through the leaves. Spring and autumn cleaning of the roof gutter.

When your gutters are left unprotected, there are higher chances or vermin or insects in finding their way inside them. If you don’t use guards, you can have everything from squirrels to mosquitoes nesting inside the gutters. Gutter guards will help minimize the amount of water that sits in the gutters. Curious how these two things are related?

When you have stagnant water inside your gutters, they will attract birds, rodents, or other insects that typically look for moisture-rich areas to nest. Aside from blocking water, the guards will physically block these pests from getting inside the gutters, further preventing any possible infestations and diseases brought by these critters.

Preventing Rust

Man cleaning gutters on ladder

People that don’t use gutter guards, will have their gutters exposed to leaves that pile up inside the gutters. With every light drizzle, these leaves gather moisture which, in turn, leads to rust and corrosion of the gutters. Because of the way in which they are constructed, gutter guards will prevent any leaves and other debris that could attract moisture from getting inside the gutters, expanding their lifespan.

Stopping Blockages

A gutter brush placed in the gutter with dried leaves on top of the gutter brush

More often than not, gutters that are left unprotected will get clogged. It’s a phenomenon that makes perfect sense, considering that gutters are exposed to all sorts of debris that, once imbued with water, becomes heavier and eventually gets stuck somewhere inside the gutter.

Naturally, gutters may begin to overflow, and this means that water can easily pour down the exterior walls or damage the foundation of the house. Aside from the obvious damage, this whole issue can cause, dirty water can also cause permanent stains on the exterior of your home, which is messy and unaesthetic.

Preventing Freeze

Leaffilter gutter image showing inside of trough and guard with water pouring through.

Another common issue with gutters that are left unprotected is the fact that water can easily freeze inside the gutter. This, in turn, creates gutter dams, which are blockages that could prevent melted ice from going down the drain. It’s true that gutter guards cannot permanently block water or winter frost, but they can reduce it significantly.

When water freezes inside the gutters, there’s also pressure put on the gutters themselves. The ice that collects inside the gutter can put a lot of strain as far as weight in concerned. In time, this could pull the gutters away from the walls, or cause dents in the surface of the gutters.

Top 7 Gutter Guards Reviews

LeafFilter Gutter Guard

LeafFilter Gutter Guard
  • Type: Micro Mesh complete enclosure
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • Material: stainless steel and uPVC
Check The Price

LeafFilter uses patented technology to assure that your gutters remain clear, which reduces the dangerous, distasteful job you have to do cleaning and helps protect your home from damage due to clogged gutters. Unlike other types of gutter guards, such as brush filters and micro-mesh covers, LeafFilter is completely enclosed, assuring that no debris gets into the gutters to clog them while still allowing the same amount of water.

Pros:

  • Completely enclosed for full protection
  • Works with existing gutters
  • Professional installation includes gutter cleaning, sealing, realignment, and reinforcement
  • Includes a lifetime warranty
  • Financing is available

Cons:

  • Costly option
  • Warranty does not include a satisfaction guarantee

Pro Tip

LeafFilter is for anyone who wants to protect their home and keep gutters from getting clogged, also negating the need to climb a ladder and clear the debris yourself.

GutterBrush Leaf Gutter Guard

GutterBrush Leaf Gutter Guard
  • Type: cylinder-shaped bristles
  • Warranty: 10 Year
  • Material: polypropylene and galvanized steel
Check The Price

The GutterBrush is an inexpensive method to keep your gutters protected. It can block leaves, as well as other chunks of large debris. It’s available in a 6-foot version, but there are longer models available if you want to cover the entire length of your gutters.

The system itself is very easy to install, and it fits the standard 5-inch width of a gutter. The brushes are simply inserted inside the gutters and can be kept there throughout the entire year. The polypropylene bristles are made with quality UV and have a wire core made from galvanized steel.

Pros:

  • Five length options.
  • Easy to install.
  • Inexpensive.
  • Made with durable polypropylene bristles.
  • Quality galvanized steel core.

Cons:

  • Still require occasional gutter cleaning.

Pro Tip

The GutterBrush is a perfect product for people who are still skeptical about spending a lot of money on a product they’ve never tested before. It’s also a viable alternative for people looking for gutter guards that are inexpensive and easy to install.

Shur Flo X Leaf Guard Gutter Protector

Shur Flo X Leaf Guard Gutter Protector
  • Type: screen gutter guard
  • Warranty: 25 years
  • Material: aluminum
Read Our Full Review Check The Price

 

The Shur Flo X gutter guard is a product that fits directly onto the gutter, unlike other options that require installing the protector under the roof shingles. This can sometimes void the warranty of your roof, so it’s always best to leave such work in the hands of professionals.

What makes the Shur Flo X stand out from other similar products? The perforated filtration system is built in such a way as to allow rainwater to pass through the surface of the guards while managing to keep debris, leaves and larger insects out of your gutters. The construction of these gutter guards also allows a generous amount of airflow to pass through its surface, keeping the gutters ventilated properly.

Pros:

  • Transferable warranty.
  • Four different color options.
  • Allows rainwater to pass through.
  • Properly ventilates the gutters.

Cons:

  • Sold as a pack of 50 panels.

Pro Tip

If you want a gutter guard that block big chunks of debris, but allows rainwater to pass through the drainage holes, the Shur Flo X is a great option. There will be a bunch of screws to mount the guards, so only pick this product if you don’t mind going through the setup process.

Amerimax Home Products 86670 Snap-in Filter Gutter Guard

Amerimax Home Products 86670 Snap-In Filter Gutter Guard
  • Type: mesh gutter guard
  • Warranty: limited lifetime
  • Material: vinyl and plastic
Read our full Review Check The Price

 

Amerimax has created a really good mesh-type kind of gutter guard, perfect for K-style gutters that measure 4, 5, or 6 inches. Because of the fine mesh surface, this particular gutter guard is perfectly capable of trapping small debris particles, as well as leaves, while also preventing all sorts of insects and critters from finding their way into the gutter system.

The guards are made from rigid PVC, making them durable in the long run. They are super-easy to install, because of their snap-on type of mechanism. Instructions are really easy to follow, and always make sure that the gutter guards are installed with the filters facing upwards.

Pros:

  • Snap-in design.
  • Easy installation.
  • Fine mesh filter.
  • Captures fine debris.

Cons:

  • Not compatible with some gutters.

Pro Tip

If you would like to spend money on a brand you can really trust, Amerimax is the right choice for you. Also, their product is great for people who don’t want to spend too much time figuring on how to install a simple set of gutter guards.

GutterStuff GSEz-K58Box K Style Foam Gutter Filter

GutterStuff GSEz-K58Box K Style Foam Gutter Filter
  • Type: foam gutter guard
  • Warranty: 3 years performance warranty
  • Material: foam
Check The Price

 

Have you ever wondered is foam gutter guards are any good? Let’s take a look at this product by GutterStuff. The foam inserts can simply slide into your gutters, and manage to successfully keep away pretty much anything that could clog your gutters.

Because they are made from foam, these types of gutter guards will allow water to pass through, while filtering our any type of debris that could get inside the gutter system. They are available for purchase for gutters of widths that vary between four and six inches. They are made with UV protection, which means they can stay under the sun’s powerful rays without suffering any damage. However, they will require changing in time, mostly because the product acts like a sponge and attracts moisture which can, in time, lead to the apparition of mold and bacteria.

Pros:

  • Easy to install.
  • Allows water to pass through.
  • Prevents gutter clogs.
  • Blocks out most debris.
  • Contains germicide.

Cons:

  • Will require replacement.

Pro Tip

If you’re a fan of foam gutter guards, this product should find its way onto your shopping list. It’s an easy-to-install type of gutter guard, but will require changing every few years.

EasyOn Gutter Guard

EasyOn Gutter Guard
  • Type: micro-mesh gutter guard
  • Warranty: 10 years
  • Material: stainless steel
READ OUR FULL REVIEW Check The Price

 

Here is the best micro-mesh options available for those of you looking for a sturdy brand for gutter guards. One of the many benefits brought by the EasyOn guards is the multiple installation method. You can either screw the gutters with the included self-tapping screws, or you can use the adhesive bond tape. Of course, you can use both methods simultaneously.

The fine surface made with micro-mesh can easily keep out the most common forms of debris and critters out of your gutters, prolonging their lifespan and leaving you with one less thing to worry about. With EasyOn, you won’t have to worry about the tedious and dangerous job of cleaning your gutters.

Pros:

  • Made with stainless steel.
  • Great filtering capacity.
  • Multiple installation methods.
  • Strong 3M tape.

Cons:

  • Could cause ice clogs.

Pro Tip

The EasyOn gutter guard is a product that appeals to a wide range of customers. Because of its dual installation method, it’s a great product for people who love versatility and freedom of choice, but also for those who strongly feel like micro-mesh gutter guards are THE way to go.

LeafGuard Gutter Guard

LeafGuard Gutter Guard
  • Type: Seamless aluminum replacement
  • Warranty: Limited lifetime
  • Material: Aluminum
Read our full review Check The Price

 

The only brand of gutter cover that is patented as a one-piece seamless gutter, LeafGuard provides coverage by having the guard integrated into the gutter rather than added on to an existing gutters. This creates the seamless approach that helps keep anything from getting into warps and cracks that can occur with other types of guards. It also assures that, even in the heaviest rains, water is directed away from your home and roof.

Pros:

  • Single piece, seamless gutter
  • Doesn’t screw into the roof, negating any potential roof leaks after installation
  • Aluminum material is thicker than average, and spout is larger
  • Limited lifetime warranty on paint finish
  • Free repairs and cleaning if damaged while you own your home
  • Custom fit to your home

Cons:

  • Requires replacement of existing gutters rather than attaching to them
  • Expensive replacement process

Pro Tip

LeafGuard is for those who may already have damage to their gutters and need a complete replacement, which offers a complete guard to avoid future damage.

Conclusion

Choosing the right gutter guard is a matter of spending time to find the product that offers the best balance between what you need from such a product vs. how much it can actually protect your gutters. We always like to think that the products we review are ultimately chosen as a matter of personal preference, but with gutter guards, it’s very important that they actually get the job done, leaving less room for subjectivism.

The best gutter guards are the ones that expand the lifespan of your gutters, the ones that manage to keep the most types of debris out of the system, but also the ones that are easiest to install. The best choice would be to choose guards that don’t require fiddling with the roof of your house, as you may void the warranty on some parts of the construction. There are tons of clip-on, snap-on or simple screw-on types of systems, so pick something that’s sturdy and not complicated to set up.

Leave a Comment

shares